Doctor operating a medical device by turning a series of dials

Human Factors Testing

Medical products can be complex and challenging to use and this can lead to human mistakes, also known as use errors, which may cause injury to patients or users. To mitigate errors, manufacturers strive to demonstrate that new products can be used in a safe and effective manner through the application of Human Factors/Usability Engineering process. Human Factors Testing becomes the focal point of the Human Factors/Usability Engineering process and valuable throughout development.

Learn more about Human Factors Testing and how Improvita can guide you through the process for those in the medical device, pharmaceutical, and combination product industries.

Our Human Factors Testing services include the following:

What are Human Factors?

In simple terms, Human Factors are attributes of the physical body, behavior, cognition, and performance that impact how a user interacts with a product. A keen understanding of how a medical product is used is essential to evaluate the possibility that the user may make a mistake that can change how the product benefits them. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has provided guidance to assist industry in following appropriate Human Factors/Usability Engineering processes to maximize the likelihood that new medical devices will be safe and effective for the intended users, uses and use environments. The goal of these tests is to put the subject product through its paces in real-world scenarios, get user input, and make any required modifications to prevent patient adverse events and use errors.

The FDA emphasizes the importance that manufacturers thoroughly evaluate how users receive information about medical devices, medication delivery systems, and medical software. This understanding should cover how people comprehend the information, make decisions, and utilize the device along with its components and controls.

Importance of Human Factors Testing

Human Factors considerations are an important and required part of the risk management process that product manufacturers utilize as part of their design controls. However, anticipating usability problems can be difficult in the early stages of development. The application of Human Factors Testing, early and often, is critical to inform risk management and maximize use safety.

As healthcare and medication delivery systems become more complicated, regulatory authorities are placing a greater focus on Human Factors Testing and user research. Anyone utilizing a medical device, whether a clinician or a patient, should be able to do so without making mistakes that jeopardize the end user’s safety or limit efficacy.

Testing involves having representative users (participants) use the product in simulated situations such as a nurse in a clinical environment, a surgeon inside an operating room, or a patient at home with connected medical equipment. Human Factors Testing for medical and medication delivery devices is critical to ensuring that the product can be used safely and effectively by its intended users in the appropriate use environment.

Benefits of Human Factors Testing

Manufacturers and Sponsors can design medical products and technologies that address a vast spectrum of user needs and patient conditions. In order to bring these innovations to market, Human Factors engineering standards must be met. A well conducted Human Factors/Usability Engineering process not only meets regulatory compliance, but enables elegant product design and instructions yielding:

  • Products that can be used safely
  • Products that are easy to use
  • Products that improve user workflow
  • User interfaces that are easier to understand
  • Shorter learning curves for product use
  • More secure connections between device accessories and components (cartridges, tubing, leads, and power cords)
  • More effective warning signals
  • Improved user comprehension of the device’s state and operation
  • Simpler controls, displays, device repair, and maintenance
  • Improved user comprehension of a patient’s present medical state
  • Reduced risk of usage mistakes
  • Decreased user dependence on user manuals
  • Reduced training and retraining requirements
  • Reduced likelihood of recalls

Special considerations in Human Factors Testing

When conducting Human Factors Testing, research and development teams take certain questions into consideration. These include:

Who Are the Device Users?

To determine the product’s intended users and patient populations, careful consideration of the unique characteristics of the population is needed. It is important to explore how the user might use the product, and what’s important to them as they use the product. A user’s abilities regarding the product can be determined by personal traits such as:

  • Physical size, stamina, and strength
  • Physical dexterity, coordination, and flexibility
  • Age
  • Training, education, and experience
  • Sensory abilities (tactile sensitivity, hearing, vision)
  • Memory and other cognitive abilities
  • The health issue for which the product is utilized
  • Comorbidities (numerous ailments or diseases)
  • Literacy and linguistic abilities
  • General health condition
  • Mental and emotional condition
  • Level of health and education literacy in relation to the medical condition under consideration
  • General knowledge of comparable types of equipment

What Environment Will the Device be Used In?

In order for the Human Factors Testing to represent the genuine usage of a product, the testing environment must model the intended real-world environment as much as possible. There are many environmental characteristics that can be customized in Human Factors Testing facilities based on the intended use of the product, such as light, sound, and temperature. Other considerations include the location for intended product use, such as at home, in a hospital, or in a doctor’s office.

At Improvita, our Human Factors Testing facility offers the flexibility to customize the space based on the real-world environment that the product is intended to be used in. For example, a testing facility room could be staged as an operating room to simulate a hospital use environment or as a kitchen to simulate an at-home use environment.

What is the User Interface?

The product user interface includes all points of interaction between the product and the user. This is often broader than many people think, as it includes packaging, all components, accompanying documentation, and even training in some cases. The user interface should be evaluated across the entire device life cycle, from setup (unpacking, assembly), usage, maintenance and through disposal. Key considerations are:

  • Weight, shape, and size of the product
  • Displays, indicator lights, and visual and auditory alerts are examples of elements that offer information to the user
  • Product software components’ graphical user interfaces
  • The format in which information is delivered to the user, including feedback
  • Packaging and labeling, which may include training materials, operating instructions, and other information

FAQs

Human Factors Testing is a key component of the Human Factors/Usability Engineering process, which is required for most products across the medical industry. This includes medical device manufacturers, SaMD, In Vitro Diagnostics, Combination Drug Delivery products, Sample Collection devices, and certain prescription and OTC drugs. Planning and executing a Human Factors Engineering process is also required for products to be in compliance with IEC 62366, as is typical for UK, EU, and other world markets. Finally, products intended for market in the United States, which have critical tasks that could cause user or patient harm if a use error occurs, must conduct Human Factors testing.

With the purpose of minimizing use-related hazards and ensuring users can use the device effectively and safely, the best time to integrate Human Factors Engineering is as early as possible in the product development cycle to have maximum impact and produce the best possible user interface and product design.

Every class of medical device can benefit from Human Factors Testing, but Human Factors Testing can become necessary if the device’s use errors pose serious harm to the patients or end users.

Why Choose Improvita for Human Factors Testing?

Human Factors Testing is a vital investment when human lives are at stake. At Improvita, we have a depth of experience having successfully completed Human Factors Testing for products across many sectors of the medical device, pharmaceutical and healthcare industries. We can perform studies in our well-equipped Wisconsin-based facility or other regions across the United States. In addition to Human Factors services, we provide a comprehensive range of medical device development to generate evidence that products can be used safely and effectively in the real world.

To learn more about Improvita’s Human Factors Testing consulting services, contact us to discuss your specific needs.